[He lifts the cup, and lo, she is right!]

Aaah, I suppose I owe you a secret, hm?

[He thinks silently for a moment. She probably wouldn't believe the whole thing about being a god for a few days...]

How about...how I stowed away on Cortez's ship by a complete and total accident? And it was bound for the New World at the time, to make matters worse. Not exactly one of our most shining moments, there.